Hibernian's Martin Boyle Penalty Controversy Re-Analyzed
Hibernian's Martin Boyle penalty controversy has been re-analyzed by ex-refs chief Keith Hackett, who has praised Steven McLean's decision to award the spot kick in Hibernian vs Motherwell.
Speaking exclusively to Football Insider, Hackett stated that the penalty was the correct call, citing a 'careless challenge' from Motherwell's Dylan Williams.
What Happened?
The controversy arose during Hibernian's clash with Motherwell on Sunday, August 3, when Martin Boyle won and converted a penalty in the 56th minute. The decision was met with skepticism by some, including Chris Sutton, but was backed by Kris Boyd and James McFadden.
Why It Matters for Hibernian
The decision to award the penalty had a significant impact on the game, with Hibernian ultimately losing 2-1. However, Hackett's analysis suggests that the referee made the correct call, and that the penalty was a turning point in the match.
What Comes Next?
Hibernian's chances of relegation in the 2026-27 season are still uncertain, with the team currently sitting 19 points behind leaders Heart of Midlothian. Despite a disappointing start to the season, Hibs are still in contention for a top-six finish, with a recent form of 3W-0D-2L.
League standing (final 2025 table -- new season not yet under way): 5th in Premiership, 51 pts, 13W-12D-8L from 33 games, recent form LWWLL. Goals this season: 51 scored, 37 conceded (+14 goal difference).
